求 10g switch 建議

indigo

留意緊 10g switch，主要睇緊幾個型號

EnGenius ECS5512FP
10g poe 功能齊晒
缺點 最貴

Netgear MS510TXUP
Limited lifetime warranty
平，4x10g 4x2.5g 2xsfp+
缺點 3 風扇怕會嘈

Qnap QSW-IM1200-8C
Fanless，有8個光電混合加4個光口
缺點無 PoE

kofz

留意緊 10g switch，主要睇緊幾個型號

EnGenius ECS5512FP
10g poe 功能齊晒
缺點 最貴

Netgear MS510TXU ...
indigo 發表於 2022-3-26 20:21

ECS5512FP

既錢

夠分開買有突

MS510TXUP相對合理價

怕嘈就換晒静音貓扇

via HKEPC IR Extreme 4.2.3 - Android(4.2.0)

alanh999

A 8 port full SPF+ 10G L3 switch just costs a fraction of the price of those 3 proposed by OP, why not go with the cheaper and maturer solution?

indigo

回覆 2# kofz


    唔肯定有無 label sealed ，驚無得換
唔知呢度有無師兄用緊

indigo

回覆 3# alanh999

Thanks for your recommendation, but all of my devices are base-T copper wired, there is no reason to buy a SFP+ switch.

alanh999

回覆 5# indigo


   You can consider adding SPF+ LAN cards to your devices. The total cost of "10G SPF+ switch with SPF+ LAN cards and fiber transceivers" should still be SIGNIFICANTLY lower than any of the 10G copper switches which you mentioned.

t1174-3

ECS5512FP

MS510TXUP相對合理價

怕嘈就換晒静音貓扇

via HKEPC IR Extreme 4.2.3 ...
kofz 發表於 2022-3-26 22:27

可以換静音貓扇嗎, 好像在入面, 直徑也好小.

indigo

回覆 7# t1174-3


  唔知有無 warranty sealed，驚唔拆得啫

talcans

留意緊 10g switch，主要睇緊幾個型號

EnGenius ECS5512FP
10g poe 功能齊晒
缺點 最貴

Netgear MS510TXU ...
indigo 發表於 2022-3-26 20:21

Amazon 有comments on Netgear, 話風扇唔嘈

via HKEPC IR Extreme 4.2.3 - iOS(4.0.2)

hkitsewh

用緊Netgear MS510TXUP...
無改風扇...
好靜...